Loading [MathJax]/jax/output/HTML-CSS/jax.js

Tuesday, 23 July 2024

Complex Chicanery


I came across an interesting video on YouTube, uploaded today on a channel named Higher Mathematics that posed the following problem:Solve for x:1x=5Clearly the problem has no solution amongst the real numbers but there turns out to be an infinity of solutions once we introduce complex numbers. The solution (with k=1,2,3 ) then unfolds:eiθ=cosθ+isinθei2kπ=cos2kπ+isin2kπ=1(ei2kπ))x=5ei2kπx=5lnei2kπx=ln5i2kπx=ln5x=ln5i2kπ =iln52kπThe complex numbers for values of x given by k=1,2,3 are shown in Figure 1. They all map to the point 5+0i.


Figure 1

Thus we have a function f(x) with its domain D being the countably infinite set of points:((0,iln52kπ) where k=1, 2, 3, ...) that maps all these points to (5,0i) so that:f(x)(5,0i) for all x in D

*********************

Let's look now at a slightly different problem:2x=xRight from the start, it can be said once again that there are no real solutions to this equality. This is clear once we graph the line y=2x and y=x where we see that there are no points of intersection. See Figure 2.


Figure 2

This problem was posed on the same YouTube channel mentioned earlier. Here is a link to the video. So how do we find if any complex numbers satisfy this equality? Firstly, we take the natural logarithms of both sides and proceed from there:2x=xln2x=lnxxln2=lnxlnxx=ln2lnxelnx=ln2lnxelnx=ln2lnxelnx=ln2W(lnxelnx)=W(ln2)lnx=W(ln2)lnx=W(ln2)x=eW(ln2)x=1eW(ln2)x0.379270.72087iwhere W is the Lambert W function that I've written about in previous posts. See The Omega Constant and the Lambert W Function (June 24th 2020) and More on the Lambert W Function (February 16th 2021). To evaluate x using Wolfram Alpha the command ProductLog[-ln(2)] needs to be used.

No comments:

Post a Comment