Showing posts with label resonance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label resonance. Show all posts

Friday, 2 July 2021

Concrete, Laplace Resonance and Heptatonic Musical Scales

My son turned 36 today while my granddaughter is aged 18 and I'm aged 72. I couldn't help noticing that the ratio of these ages 18 : 36 : 72 reduces to 1 : 2 : 4 in its simplest form.

This set me on a course to find out what was interesting, mathematically and otherwise, about this ratio. If you search for these proportions, the first thing that pops up is, oddly enough, concrete. See Figure 1.


Figure 1: source

Yes, it turns out that 1 : 2 : 4 is the ratio of cement : sand : aggregrate, by volume, required to make M15 concrete. It is also known as PCC (Plain Cement Concrete) and can be used in construction of Levelling course, bedding for footing, concrete roads, etc. The site from which the table in Figure 1 was taken has lots of calculations for figuring out weights etc. but I'm not going to go into here as it's rather boring.

When I searched for 1 : 2 : 4 planetary motion, I came up with something more interesting: 
A Laplace resonance is a three-body resonance with a 1 : 2 : 4 orbital period ratio (equivalent to a 4 : 2 : 1 ratio of orbits). The term arose because Pierre-Simon Laplace discovered that such a resonance governed the motions of Jupiter's moons Io, Europa, and Ganymede. It is now also often applied to other 3-body resonances with the same ratios, such as that between the extrasolar planets Gliese 876 c, b, and e. Three-body resonances involving other simple integer ratios have been termed "Laplace-like" or "Laplace-type".
Figure 2 shows a simulation of the Jovian moons' Laplace resonance (source):

Figure 2: The three-body Laplace resonance exhibited
by three of Jupiter's 
Galilean moons. Conjunctions are highlighted
by brief color changes.There are two Io-Europa conjunctions
(green) and three Io-Ganymede conjunctions (grey) for each
Europa-Ganymede conjunction (magenta). This diagram is not to scale.

The Laplace resonance is a particular type of orbital resonance and the eponymous Wikipedia article has a lots of examples of this and other types of resonances.


Intrinsic to the 1 : 2 : 4 proportions is the number 7. In fact (1, 2, 4) represents one of the 15 partitions of 7. This immediately to mind heptatonic musical scales:
A heptatonic scale is a musical scale that has seven pitches, or tones, per octave. Examples include:
  • the major scale or minor scale in C major: C D E F G A B C
  • the relative minor, A minor, natural minor: A B C D E F G A 
  • the melodic minor scale, A B C D E F♯G♯A ascending, 
  • the melodic minor scale, A G F E D C B A descending 
  • the harmonic minor scale, A B C D E F G♯A 
  • the Byzantine or Hungarian, scale, C D E♭ F♯ G A♭ B C.

So any partition of 7 can be viewed in terms of such a scale. Applying this to 1 : 2 : 4, there are six possible divisions. Figure 3 shows two of these:


Figure 3

I've written about musical scales more generally in my previous post titled Equal Temperament Tuning.

Sunday, 23 June 2019

Acoustic Resonance


I recently read an article about acoustic resonance frequencies within the different chambers of the Great Pyramid. I found that the speed of sound in air at a temperature of 20°C is about 343 metres per second. Now \(343 = 7^3\) and this got me thinking about the acoustic resonant frequencies of cylindrical tubes.

There is one particular formula for a tube that is closed at one end:$$f=\frac {nv}{4(L+0.4d)}$$where \(v\) is the speed of sound, \(L\) is the length of the resonant tube, \(d\) is the diameter of the tube, \(f\) is the resonant sound frequency. Here \(n\) is an odd number (1, 3, 5...) because this type of tube produces only odd harmonics and has its fundamental frequency an octave lower than that of an open cylinder (that is, half the frequency).

After a little experimentation, I found that using \(v=343\) and tube dimensions, in metres, of \(L=11.75\) and \(d=1.25\) the resultant acoustic frequencies (in hertz) were multiples of 7. Figure 1 shows a screenshot of the SageMath code that I used to confirm this:

Figure 1: calculations for a cylinder closed at one end

The formula for the acoustic resonance frequencies for a cylinder that is open at both ends is given by:$$f=\frac {nv}{2(L+0.8d)}$$and, if the length L is doubled so that \(L=23.5\) and the diameter remains the same, then the same multiples of 7 frequencies emerge as shown in Figure 2. Note that all the frequency multiples of the fundamental can occur (2, 3, 4, ... ) not just the odd multiples (3, 5, 7, ... ).

Figure 2: calculations for a cylinder open at both ends

So the takeaway from all this is that a cylinder, closed at one end and with a length of 11.25 metres and a diameter of 1.25 metres, will have a fundamental acoustic resonance frequency of 7 Hz. Similarly, a cylinder that is open and both ends but twice as long will have this same fundamental frequency. Now this has opened up a whole can of worms because this frequency has some interesting properties and takes one into the world of infrasound. Here are some interesting comments about 7 Hz and other infrasonic frequencies taken from this source.
Infrasound is low frequency audio beneath the human range of hearing. Infrasound constantly surrounds us, generated naturally; wind, waves, earthquakes and by man; building activity, traffic, air conditioners and so-on. Low frequency sound is used by marine mammals to communicate over vast distances and by birds to determine migration patterns. 
At higher volumes infrasound of around 7-20 Hz can directly affect the human central nervous system causing disorientation, anxiety, panic, bowel spasms, nausea, vomiting and eventually unconsciousness (supposedly 7-8 Hz is the most effective being the same frequency as the average brain alpha wave). The effect is unintentionally (or not?) generated by the extreme low frequencies in church pipe organ music, instilling religious feelings and causing sensations of “extreme sense sorrow, coldness, anxiety, and even shivers down the spine” in the unsuspecting congregation. Low frequency sound generated naturally or by building work and traffic is said to be the cause of reported apparitions and hauntings – blamed on the ghostly 19 Hz frequency which matches the resonating frequency of the human eyeball.
A cylinder, open at both ends with a diameter of 2.5 metres and a length of 7 metres, will produce a fundamental frequency of 19.06 Hz, the so-called "ghost frequency". I won't pursue any of this further in a mathematically-focussed blog such as this, but I'll investigate it further in one of my other blogs.